One recurring theme of this blog has been the relentless attacks on victims of motor accidents by the insurance industry and their friends in government. The constant justification for this has been that car insurance premiums are too high and that so called ‘reforms’ will benefit all of us.
Former MOJ Minister Helen Grant nailed her colours to the mast back in 2013 –
“These proposals were advanced in a consultation exercise which closed on 4 January (2013) and, together with wider civil law reforms, are intended to make lawyers’ costs proportionate, and create an environment where insurers can pass on savings to their customers through lower premiums.”
It is fair to say that there has been some scepticism surrounding these claims. Back in 2013 we saw huge cuts in the amounts of legal costs recoverable by victims. Even then a representative from LVI said - ‘premiums have already come down and we might see about 3% but - “I’m not hopeful of much more” ‘
I said back then that we might have a long wait before we saw any significant reduction –
In August 2013 we saw the report of the Parliamentary Committee on Whiplash Claims. This mentioned the familiar question of reductions in premiums –
‘We recommend that the Government explain how it will monitor whether or not motor insurers honour their commitment to ensure that any cost reductions resulting from proposed legal reforms are passed through to consumers in the form of lower premiums.’
Into 2014 the ABI were still going on about a ‘whiplash epidemic’, despite growing evidence that the number of claims was dropping. In other words – don’t expect any drop in premiums while there is still this mythical epidemic!
In April 2015 we were warned that motor premiums were going up! And they were going up because of dodgy whiplash claims. This announcement was made in the run up to the General Election when we all had our minds on other things –
Then in November 2015 the former Chancellor George Osborne announced further attacks including the proposed abolition of the right to seek damages for whiplash at all –
Part of his reasoning was that this would see a reduction in motor premiums. He even put a figure on the saving that we could all expect. He said premiums would come down by about £3-£4 a month. Did he know that he would not be around long enough to justify his claims!
So where does that leave us today?
We have over 3 years of attacks; cuts and rhetoric that makes victims look like criminals. Surely we must start to see some savings.
In fact it is the opposite.
The Times has recently reported that premiums have in fact gone up by a fifth in the last 12 months. The report, covered by Legal Futures, went on –
“It suggests that the overall cost to the insurance industry of these claims has dropped from more than £4.1bn in 2013 to £3.6bn last year. Motor insurance prices, however, have actually risen over the past 12 months.”
So has the penny finally dropped?
Those representing claimants have been banging their heads against the wall trying to get this message across. The cuts have all been about maximizing the profits of the insurance industry. No serious commentator has ever expected any benefits to be passed on to drivers.
It is a shame that it has taken this long. But let’s hope that the government will now stick to its word.
The ‘reforms’ were built on a lie.
There was never any real chance that we would all get cheaper insurance. The government should now say enough is enough. Now is the time to roll back the cuts.
Will it happen?